Three years into the Consumer Duty, the FCA's message to firms has narrowed to one point: collecting data is not the same as showing customers get good outcomes. In its review of year-two board reports in April 2026, the regulator said firms had presented plenty of data without explaining what it showed, and told them to go past management information dashboards to analysis that draws conclusions. Its review of outcomes monitoring, published on 27 July 2026, went further and described what the evidence should look like.
That review created no new rules or deadlines. What it did was make clear what good looks like, with separate expectations for smaller firms. For a mortgage brokerage, IFA or wealth manager without a data team, it is the most useful piece of supervisory material the FCA has published on the Duty, because it shows that a focused set of measures, used properly, is enough.
| Date | Publication | The point for smaller firms |
|---|---|---|
| 24 Feb 2026 | Board reports page updated with smaller-firm insight | Smaller firms can use more targeted MI and a knowledgeable critical friend in place of formal compliance functions |
| 16 Apr 2026 | Observations on year-two board reports | Link data to conclusions, document board challenge, monitor outcomes delivered through third parties |
| 29 Jun 2026 | CP26/23 on scope and proportionality | Proposals include letting firms fold Duty reporting into business-as-usual reporting rather than a standalone report |
| 27 Jul 2026 | Outcomes monitoring: good practice and areas for improvement | Define good outcomes, justify thresholds, and keep a trail from MI to decision to tested result |
The single biggest gap the FCA found was definitional. Weaker firms had one broad statement of what a good outcome is and a list of indicators, and some used activity measures, such as conversion rates or the number of reviews completed, as a stand-in for customer outcomes. Those numbers describe what the firm did. They do not say whether the customer ended up in a good position.
Stronger firms described what a good outcome looks like at each stage of the journey for their main products: when the client is onboarded, advised, supported through completion and served afterwards. For smaller firms, the FCA described a clear and workable approach as focusing on the main product and the key stages, describing good outcomes in plain language, and using a small number of existing indicators such as complaints, customer feedback, missed service standards and file checks.
This is a starting point for a mortgage or financial advice firm. Pick the measures that fit your products and customers, and drop any you cannot act on.
| Outcome | Example measures | Where the data usually lives |
|---|---|---|
| Products and services | File check pass rate by adviser; cases outside the stated target market | Compliance file reviews, back office or CRM |
| Price and value | Fees against case complexity; ongoing service delivered against ongoing charges taken | Back office, fee records, review diary |
| Consumer understanding | Client queries after the recommendation; comprehension checks for vulnerable clients | CRM notes, call logs, feedback surveys |
| Consumer support | Response times; days from application to offer; complaints by root cause; outcomes for vulnerable clients by driver | CRM, case tracker, complaints log |
The FCA also flagged vulnerability MI that was aggregated rather than split by driver, such as health, financial resilience or life events. Low volumes make detailed splits hard for small firms, and the regulator accepts that, but it expects you to show you have considered whether different groups get the support they need.
Many firms in the review set thresholds they could not justify. The FCA gave the example of a firm with thresholds for complaints, file review pass rates, client retention and mortgage review engagement that could not consistently explain where they came from. A smaller firm in the good practice examples set its thresholds from a mix of its own history, available benchmarks and senior management judgement, and wrote the reasoning down.
A simple test works: for every threshold, can you say in one sentence why breaching it suggests a customer might be harmed? If not, change it or drop it.
The heart of the July review is traceability. The FCA wants a firm to show what its information told it, how that pointed to a risk, what action followed, and whether the action worked. For a small firm, that can be a single issues and actions log with these columns:
The last column is the one most firms skip. The FCA was explicit that agreeing an action, or introducing a new checklist, does not on its own show that outcomes improved.
Most of these measures already exist in your back office, CRM, complaints log and file reviews. The work is in pulling them into one place each month without someone copying and pasting. Connect those sources to a single dashboard that refreshes automatically, set the thresholds once, and have breaches appear in the issues log for a person to review. AI can help by summarising free-text feedback and complaint notes into themes, but the decision about what to do, and the record of it, stays with the senior individual responsible for the Duty.
EYRA builds outcomes MI dashboards and issues logs for advice and wealth firms, drawing on the systems you already use. Our review maps where your Duty data lives today, which measures are worth keeping and where the evidence trail breaks. We then build the dashboard and log so the numbers come from formulas you can audit, client data stays under proper access controls, and your board report becomes an export rather than a project. We don't replace your compliance adviser; we give them evidence that is easier to work with.
Enough to show whether customers are getting good outcomes across products and services, price and value, consumer understanding and consumer support, with analysis that draws conclusions and leads to action.
No. The FCA accepts a focused set of existing indicators, such as complaints, feedback, missed service standards and file checks, as long as the firm can show how it identifies and addresses harm.
The July 2026 outcomes monitoring review created no new rules or deadlines. CP26/23, published in June 2026, consulted on changes to scope and proportionality.
The results of outcomes monitoring, any evidence of poor outcomes, the actions taken and whether they worked, and how future strategy fits with delivering good outcomes.
Yes, for summarising feedback, spotting themes in complaints and flagging breaches. Decisions and accountability stay with named senior people.
Book a review
Tell us a little about your firm and what's taking up your team's time. We'll reply within two working days to set up a 20-minute call. If we're not the right fit, we'll say so.